Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 With sorrow and regret, Smith declares cooling-off period with Israel 

With sorrow and regret, Smith declares cooling-off period with Israel

Stephen Smith at the press conference today announcing Australia will expel an Israeli diplomat over forged passports used in an assassination of a Hamas leader. Photo: Glen McCurtayne

Australia’s Foreign Minister, Stephen Smith, is a man who takes the nostrum ''in foreign affairs words are bullets'' very seriously indeed.

So when Smith used words like ''sorrow'' and ''regrettable'' when he announced today that the Australian Government would expel an Israeli diplomat over the Dubai fake passport affair, it was a sign that the relationship between the two countries has been seriously damaged by the incident.

In a press conference today Smith disclosed the findings of investigations by Australian police and intelligence agencies into the use of four Australian passports in an operation to assassinate a Hamas commander in Dubai in January.

He said the investigation had reached three conclusions.

Firstly, there was absolutely no evidence that any of the four Australian passport holders had been anything other than victims of deliberate passport fraud.

Secondly, the nature of the counterfeiting and cloning of the passports was so sophisticated that it could only have been effected by a nation state through its intelligence services.

Thirdly, the evidence established ''beyond doubt'' that Israel was responsible.

''Regrettably this is not the first occasion on which Australian passports have been misused by Israel,'' he told the press conference.

''Regrettably what occurred in this Dubai incident is contrary and in breach of understandings reached between Australia and Israel of some years standing.''

Smith received the final results of the investigation last week.

He took a recommendation to cabinet's national security committee this morning to retaliate by expelling an Israeli diplomat from Tel Aviv's embassy in Canberra within the week.

''The decision was made much more in sorrow than in anger,'' he said.

''Australia and Israel are firm friends and that remains the case but this was not the act of a friend.''

The language of sorrow and regret deployed by the Foreign Minister is significant given Smith's normally highly cautious demeanour and the Australian government's long record of support for Israel.

This is a bipartisan stance in Australian politics and one that has served Tel Aviv's national interests.

In December 2008, for instance, Israel was being widely criticised in the international community for the ferocity of its air strikes against Hamas targets in the Gaza strip.

The then acting prime minister Julia Gillard defended Tel Aviv, saying Hamas had started the violence with its rocket and mortar attacks on Israel.

While the friendship has not been permanently damaged, there will clearly be a period of more distant relations. Smith said Australia would reduce co-operation with Israel on intelligence and security.

''Cleary as a result of today's events there will be something of a cooling-off period so far as relevant agencies are concerned,'' he said.

''We would want very much for those co-operative relationships to proceed but there does require a rebuilding of trust and confidence.''

Mark Davis is the national editor

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The problem with Israel is that the country's leaders and its agencies seem to think that they can do whatever, whenever and wherever they please with a little support from the US no doubt. The passport incident just highlights the fact that Israel is a nuclear-armed rogue state, no more no less. It has no regard for internationally human rights convention, UN resolutions and by all accounts, human life itself. The only way that Israel can now make progress in terms regaining any credibility as well as peace is by withdrawing to pre-1967 defensive lines and to return stolen land and propery to their rightfull owners. In terms of Australia's response, I am of the view that the response was way too meak and mild this given the seriousness of the passport issue involved. But then, better a late and mild response rather than not one at all.
Posted by Henk Luf, 24/05/2010 3:52:58 PM
What would happen to me if I faked an Australian passport in order to go overseas with someone else's identity to commit a murder? A slap on the wrist?
Posted by Alice, 24/05/2010 7:58:27 PM
To Henk Luf, I ask, Are we a rogue country? If Israel is a rogue state? Should Australia's Leaders also withdraw to pre-1770 borders because of the lack of regard for human rights and by all accounts, human life itself, when acquiring this country from its rightful owners?? And from my perspective and extensive reading, although we have have said "sorry" to the indigenous peoples of our country, INJUSTICE is still occurring on a daily basis to the Indigenous People of this land. And just say, if the Indigenous people of this land were to terrorise the "invaders" [for that is what we really are], no matter which way we like to look at it, and receive finance from well-known [terrorist organisations to enable them to do so, would we just sit back and not defend ourselves??? Hardly!! I agree that Israel should be made to account for using Australian citizens passports, but get real... And remember...what's good for the goose is good for the gander!! Nuf said!
Posted by Linda , 25/05/2010 3:44:33 PM
Who the bloody hell do they think they are?? is em off.
Posted by Don At Devonport, 25/05/2010 5:03:38 PM
I assume that if an American is caught using a forged Australian passport that the same action will be taken?
Posted by bill, 26/05/2010 8:11:22 AM
If anyone of us was apprehended travelling with a stolen or forged passport we would be facing a jail sentence. But I guess, Israel considers itself in a league of its own and above the law. `pity the people whose passports they used. These victims have now become targets of Israel's enemies!
Posted by Marie Jacqueline Lee, 26/05/2010 5:04:43 PM
To Linda I respond. If 1770 were 1970 then Australia could well have been regarded as a rogue State in which case Linda's notion, comparing Australia and Israel, would be correct.. Bad as both cases are, there are similarities in both instances. Both involved land-grabs, invasion by force, human right abuses, the only difference being the time factor. Just as israel needs to comply within the boundaries of International Law, so does Australia and neither country does so.
Posted by Henk Luf, 26/05/2010 5:58:28 PM
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!
Stephen Smith
Stephen Smith

Most popular articles




Roxby Downs Sun







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...